Toxic mushrooms kill hundreds in China

By AAP/Tini Tran with AG STAFF 14 July 2010
Reading Time: 3 Minutes Print this page
The mysterious deaths of 400 people in China have been pinned on a tiny, innocuous-looking mushroom.

EVERY SUMMER DURING THE height of the rainy season, villagers of all ages in a corner of southwestern China would suddenly die of cardiac arrest. No one knew what caused Yunnan Sudden Death Syndrome, blamed for an estimated 400 deaths in the past three decades.

Now, after a five-year investigation, an elite investigative unit from China’s Centre for Disease Control and Prevention believes it has pinpointed the cause: an innocuous-looking small mushroom known as the little white.

The search for the culprit began in 2005 and took investigators to remote villages spread over the rural highlands of Yunnan province, says Robert Fontaine, an epidemiologist with the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

There was “this very obvious clustering of deaths in villages in very short periods of time in the summer,” says Robert, who helped in the investigation. “It appears that there was something a little different going on.”

Local health officials had noted the deaths for years. In 2004, they appealed to Beijing for assistance. The government gave the task to the China Field Epidemiology Training Programme; a unit of medical investigators at China’s CDC assigned some of the country’s toughest health mysteries.

THE MEDICAL TEAMS ENCOUNTERED obstacles. Many villagers didn’t speak standard Chinese, instead communicating in their own dialect. Villages were scattered in often remote areas. Rapid burials made it difficult to conduct autopsies. Torrential rain and mudslides hampered travel. But that first year, investigators were able to narrow down the list of possibilities: most victims had drunk surface water, they had emotional stress and they ate mushrooms.

The investigators zeroed in on mushrooms, because the deaths were closely aligned with the harvesting season. More than 90 per cent of the deaths occurred in July or August. By the end of 2005, investigators began issuing warnings to some villages to avoid eating unfamiliar mushrooms.

That was a difficult order to follow. Yunnan province is legendary for its wide variety of wild mushrooms, many of which are exported at high prices. Entire families go out to hunt for them during the summer months.

By 2008, investigators had discovered a relatively unknown mushroom in a number of homes where people had died. The mushroom is not usually sold in the markets, because it’s too small. “We repeatedly found it at all these sites,” Robert says.

A public information campaign to warn against eating the mushrooms has dramatically reduced the number of deaths. Only a handful have been reported in the last couple of years, and none so far this year.

HOWEVER, THE MYSTERY HAS not yet been definitively solved. Testing found the mushroom contained some toxins, though not enough to be deadly. Chinese scientists need to isolate the toxin and test whether it triggers cardiac arrests.

Researchers have hypothesised that there is a second agent. Many of the victims showed high levels of barium, a heavy metal in the soil that seeps into mushrooms. “There is a lot of work left to do,” Robert says. “We really need additional lab investigations.”

“Eating any mushroom other than well-characterised, store-bought types such as shiitake, is like playing Russian roulette with six shooter containing five bullets,” Dr Bryan Grieg Fry, an expert on venoms and toxins at the University of Melbourne, told Australian Geographic.

“There may be an accumulative effect, where additional damage occurs through several meals containing the mushrooms,” Bryan says. “Secondly, the high concentration of barium in the mushrooms may indeed point to a synergistic effect between this man-made pollutant and the toxins within the mushroom. This highlights the much more fundamental problem of human activities creating a poisonous planet.”

Problems with poisonous mushrooms are common throughout Asia, adds Diderik De Vleeschauwer, a spokesman for the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation regional office in Thailand.  “Normally we expect people to have knowledge of what they can and can’t eat. One would think there is indigenous knowledge available about what they can forage,” he says. “But these are accidents that can happen.”